What Would You Do To Save Someone You Loved?

The current project I am working on deals with a person that does some really bad things.  This person recognizes they are bad but does them to prove a point and to start something that is not readily apparent to the reader until towards the end of the story.

I am attempting to have the reader understand what the character is doing, not necessarily agree with him, but understand it.  One of the  greatest things a story can accomplish is to have the consumer question something that they believed they already knew the answer to.  This story would be a success if I could get the reader to question or at the very least re-examine their morals.

My inspiration for this story has to do with a question I read in a short story, “What would you do in order to save someone you loved?”.  That is very interesting to me.  How far would you go?  What would you sacrifice?  For my story the character isn’t trying to save a individual person he is trying to save something that is not entirely tangible, innocence.

The concept of innocence will probably end up being a completely separate blog post in the future, but it also interests me.  Everyone loses their “innocence” at some point growing up.  This can be as simple as learning there is no Santa Claus, learning your parents are fallible, to something much darker like physical/sexual abuse, losing a loved one, etc.  Now some people believe that physical/sexual abuse is passed from one generation to the next.  A person that was abused is more likely to abuse someone in their lifetime.  So someone who has their innocence stolen from them is more likely to do the same to someone else.

So a question my character may ask would be, would you be willing to end the life of one person in order to save a dozen?  If no, would you be willing to take this same person’s life in order to save your family?  And if the question is yes to the 2nd question what does that say about yourself?  You would kill to save someone you loved but not a stranger who also has people that care for them.  If you think that it is only justifiable if you love the person you are trying to save what if your beliefs cause you to have the same affinity for groups of people and not just a single individual?

My struggle is to enter the mind of someone who would think in these shades of grey and not make him out to be a monster.  Sometimes I enjoy it other times it is truly a struggle.  Yet the reason I love to write and tell stories is the ability to step into another’s shoes and see the world as they see it.  So if it disturbs me at times then hopefully it will do the same for the reader, and the ability to elicit emotion is one of writers greatest tools!



Filed under Writing

5 responses to “What Would You Do To Save Someone You Loved?

  1. What would I do to save a love one? If I have to offer mine so I can save my wife’s or my son’s, then let it be. As for innocence, the best examples are the children around us. My son embodies that. I was once like him but as I get older, the Earthly, materialistic influence took it away. I’m lucky to have a son that reminds me of what innocence and simplicity are and all I have to do is look into his eyes.great post.

  2. It reminds me of the Heinlein Question from Starship Troopers, how much is a life worth?

    Say you were president and some militant dictator took some girl scouts hostage. If you don’t invade and liberate them, hundreds of thousands of soldiers will be sent to war and some will die. If you do nothing, they will be killed to mock your ‘fascist imperialism’.

    Which is the right answer? It is similar to the two boats in The Dark Knight, where innocent people and convicts were given the trigger to each other’s bombs.

    The problem with whatever answer you choose, the person acting has to make a decision, and it is one that is one of the hardest questions in the world, in my opinion.

    How much is a life worth? If somebody says priceless, the implications of that are enormous.

  3. if you invade first, if you don’t second. I win at the internet.

  4. What a great question! I hope I never have to chose to hurt someone to help my family. But a novel is a really good place to explore this question. You can test yourself with hypothetical options without having any of the messy real-world consequences.

  5. I would defiantly do the second to save my family if that was the outcome imminent if I didn’t act ….

    Take Care…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s